الاخ علاء
في مجموعت مقالتك الاخيره ربط بين مصائب العالم كلها و بين الوهابيين و هذا الربط الغير موضوعي او المنطقي حول مقالتك الي مجموعه من الافكار الغير مترابطه او موضعيه تبداء باتهام من غير سند و تنتهيبالحل هو الديمقراطيه ..... التي ليست لها علاقه بالموضوع اصلا مثل موضوع جسد المرأه
ان حشرك الغير موضوعي للوهابيين و مللوك البترول في كل الموضيع يجعل القارئ في شك وحيره من هدفك الحقيقي , هل هو ثأر بينك و بين الملوك أو انك تبحث عن معركه وهميه مع من تعتقد انهم قوي مؤثره و هم لا يعتقدون انك ذو وزن يذكر
اذا كنت تبحث عن معركه و تأيد عليك بخطه د هاله مصطفي , عزومه للسفير الاسرائيلي علي اكله فطير و اخبارك ستملئ الكون و يمكن ينوبك منحه و حتي لجوء سياسي و مين عارف انت و شطرتك
علاء
أفق من هذه المعارك الوهميه قبل فوت الاوان و خساره قرائك و ان كنت اشك ان كتابك القادم سيكون عن واهبي منحل الاخلاق
أفق من هذه المعارك الوهميه قبل فوت الاوان و خساره قرائك و ان كنت اشك ان كتابك القادم سيكون عن واهبي منحل الاخلاق
مهاجر مصري
السلام عليكم أخي الكريم
ReplyDeleteدائما ما يحمل بعضنا البعض أخطاءنا
كأننا ملائكة وغيرنا هم الشياطين
والله أعلم بالنيات
تقديري
Hi Mohajer,
ReplyDeleteI'm not good with Arabic typing, so it's either English or Franco. I agree that Al Aswany may be repeating himself a bit, but don't you think you are being too harsh on him? Even though he brings up the topic of Wahhabism unnecessarily (like in the Stockholm syndrome article on al Shorouk website), he does have legitimate concerns, don't you think so?
I think his constant attack on Wahhabism has a personal element in it. I am an amateur writer, so I can tell. Though I still think he makes a very good point when he discusses the Wahhabi/Salafi influence on Egypt.
Dear Friend,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comment
I have no sympathy for a famous writer who mix personal element with a very sensitive public issue.
Do I have a concern about the influence Wahhabi/Salafi in the Egyptian culture, sure I do.
But the fact is Wahhabi is like many other phenomena at the Egyptian society, just are symptoms and not the real cause. There is a tremendous vacuum in the Egyptian culture including respectable religious leadership as well as music, politics, art, etc…….
What we are calling Wahhabi teachings is just filling a void that we created ourselves. It is the same when we are complaining and accusing Iran and Turkey for leading the Middle East because there are no leaders around.
The government, seculars and libraries were very happy to remove all the Egyptian Islamic leaders with their plan to create a secular country. Now, they are surprised to see people need religion.
Wahhabi is nothing new, it existed for a very long time, and Egyptian always went to Saudi Arabia and the gulf but in the old days, the Arab listened to Sheik Saharawi, Um Kolthoum and read Nagib Mahfouz and AlAzahar as leader
Regards,
Mohajer Masry
الله يهدي الأمة
ReplyDeleteأضم صوتي الى صوتك لنرتقي بالكلمات و لنعف أقلامنا بما ينفعنا في ديننا ودنيانا ولا يكون حجة علينا يوم لا ينفع الندم
لك مني تحية وسلام
Dear Mohajer,
ReplyDeleteYou are right, Al Aswany should not mix personal sentiments with public issues. But he definitely has a point. When I channel surf and watch Al Nas or Al Rahma, I feel grossed out. The Egyptian people are being consumed by a culture of fake religious exteriors. The moderate Al Azhar no longer has any credibility and people are getting their information on religion from extremist sources.
However, I think you will be happy (as am I) that Al Aswany's latest article does not contain the word "Waddabi" :
http://www.shorouknews.com/Columns/Column.aspx?id=148044
Btw, I am following your comments on Bikya Masr. You make interesting points (especially on Morris Sadek's posts)